How Do We Know if a Beatification or Canonization is or not of God?By their fruits, ye shall know them (Saint Matthew 7:20).

<< Controversial Canonizations: Uncomfortable Questions >>

Basilica S. Pietro

By the Una Voce Miami Doctrinal Studies Commission
October 13th, 2018 | 101st Anniversary of the Miracle of the Sun, also known as the Miracle of Fátima, occurring on October 13th, 1917

YES. CATHOLICS throughout the world have reacted in shock and disbelief at the beatification and canonization of individuals publicly linked to ideas, policies, practices, and ideologies shrouded in doctrinal controversy and debate. What is the underlying agenda, they ask, behind the beatification and/or canonization of these individuals, done, to boot, under post-Vatican II, dramatically relaxed, non-infallible rules and regulations?

Why are these beatifications and canonizations being hastily rushed in the face of doubt, scandal, and opposition by so many people, including Catholics of unquestionable fidelity to the Church’s Magisterium? Why are they being conducted by means of a visibly politicized and ideologically tainted process often lacking in transparency, openness, and accountability? What are the people of the world to think of all the reported and highly embarrassing wheeling and dealing, subterfuge, and intrigue surrounding them?

Lacking sufficient guarantees establishing them as an actual and formal use of the Papal Magisterium, faithful Catholics ask: are modern-day canonizations infallible, and therefore reliable? If they are not, what are the practical implications of these non-infallible pronouncements? Are Catholics obligated to accept as “saints,” in the traditional sense of the term, individuals canonized under the new, completely revamped rules which abolished the traditional understanding of the concepts of “heroic virtue” and sanctity? These and many other inconvenient questions trouble faithful Catholics throughout the world.

How can we know if a beatification and/or canonization is of God or not? Let’s ask. Shouldn’t beatifications and canonizations be the source of joy, unity, and strengthening of the bonds of faith for the entire Church? Aren’t they supposed to bring all of us together? Should they ever fuel discord, scandal, or controversy? Why are people everywhere so concerned about the modern-day beatification and canonization process being abused or exploited by those seeking to advance worldly interests, ideological causes, or political agendas? 

The Catholic world asks: What kind of “pastoral policy” could possibly justify imposing on the Universal Church beatifications and/or canonizations that undermine the Church’s unity; scandalize the Church’s faithful, or otherwise disturb the peace within Christ’s Mystical Body? Would a caring, responsible shepherd, one who is zealous for souls, ever force on his flock anything that harms, confuses, or scatters it?


Doesn’t the mere fact that a beatification or canonization provokes such heated controversy and public scandal among the Catholic faithful, or that they are imposed on the Church through dubious or questionable means, constitute irrefutable proof that these controversial beatifications and canonizations are not of God, but, rather, of a destructive spirit, diametrically opposed to the faith, the holiness, and the unity of Christ’s Church?

Would Popes John XXIII, Paul VI, or John Paul II ever favor or support beatifying or canonizing anyone, including themselves, were it to stoke the fires of controversy, rancor, or scandal? What true shepherd, one who loves his sheep, would ever impose a non-essential, non-doctrinal pronouncement that provokes even the slightest injury or incites the least discord or division?

Should anyone, in good conscience, ignore these extremely relevant, albeit uncomfortable questions, grounded, as they are, on sound logic, right reason, and the common sense of people of all religions, faiths, ideologies or philosophies? Don’t these questions deserve honest, forthright answers? Isn’t it a grave disservice to the Universal Church to pretend that these questions do not exist or to marginalize or attack those who humbly ask them?

Pope Francis, we eagerly await your answer. Please, do not fail us, Your Holiness.

Ad Maiorem Dei Gloriam!

>>> The Mass of Tradition is the Mass of All Times;
it’s the Mass of the Present and the Future! <<<

For interviews, comments, or to belong, please contact us at:
San Antonio Maria Claret Chapter
POB 350372 | Jose Marti Station | Miami, FL 33135
Meet Us on the Internet

View Us on YouTube

Like Una Voce Miami on Facebook

Copyright © 2021 Una Voce Miami

About Una Voce Miami

Faithful to Catholic Tradition. Fiel a la Tradición católica. ENGLISH VERSION ----- Versión en español le sigue ----- Una Voce Miami is the Archdiocese of Miami chapter of the International Federation Una Voce (FIUV), a lay Roman Catholic organization, recognized by the Holy See. With Pope Benedict XVI's widely-acclaimed motu proprio "Summorum Pontificum" as the catalyst, Una Voce faithfully works for the universal celebration of the centuries-old Traditional Latin Mass or Extraordinary Form of the Mass. The Holy Father believes Una Voce provides a "valuable service" to the Church. We undertake this service of love with the utmost respect, charity, and goodwill deserved by our Archbishop, Mons. Thomas G. Wenski, and all the dedicated clergy under whose spiritual direction we so happily serve. Una Voce Miami asks your prayers, your support, and your enthusiasm! Will you join us in this joyful and fruitful endeavor? You are cordially invited to work with us! Please contact us at VERSIÓN EN ESPAÑOL Una Voce Miami es el capítulo de la Arquidiocesis de Miami de la Federación Internacional Una Voce (FIUV), una organización de laicos católicos reconocida por la Santa Sede. Una Voce trabaja fielmente por la celebración universal de la bi-milenaria Misa Tradicional en Latín o Rito Extraordinario de la Misa. El mundialmente aclamado Motu Proprio del Papa Benedicto XVI, "Summorum Pontificum", es el catalizador de este importante esfuerzo. El Santo Padre cree que Una Voce rinde un "servicio valioso" a la Iglesia. Nosotros desarrollamos este servicio de amor con el mayor respeto, caridad y buena voluntad merecidos por nuestro arzobispo Tomas G. Wenski y todo el clero dedicado bajo cuya dirección espiritual felizmente servimos. ¡A Una Voce Miami le faltan tus oraciones, tu apoyo y tu entusiasmo! ¿Te unirás a nosotros en este empeño jubiloso y fructífero? ¡Estas cordialmente invitado a trabajar junto a nosotros! Por favor contáctenos en
This entry was posted in GREETINGS! - ¡SALUDOS!. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s